Indians have always had a special place in their hearts for gold, whether it’s for weddings, festivals, or to have a safety net when things are uncertain. You do not need to keep heavy jewellery or gold coins in a vault to invest these days. You can enjoy the benefits of gold without having to store it in real life with contemporary options like Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) and Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). The two options are both tied to gold prices, but they work in very different ways. For example, the way you make money, how they are taxed, and how easy it is to buy and sell them are all different.
In today’s blog, we will learn about the pros and cons of each option, as well as the taxation, so you can choose the one that works best for your investment style.
What are Sovereign Gold Bonds?
Sovereign Gold Bonds, or SGBs, are an effective and simple way to invest in gold without having to buy it. You can trust SGBs completely because the government gives them out through the Reserve Bank of India.
You don’t have to keep gold at home or in a safe; instead, you buy these bonds that keep track of the price of gold. So, when the price of gold goes up, the value of your investment goes up too.
Read More: What is Sovereign Gold Bonds?
What are Gold ETFs
Gold Exchange-Traded Funds, or ETFs for simple terms, are an easy way to invest in gold without having to buy and hold the precious metal.
Consider it this way: you buy “units” of gold from the stock market rather than storing gold coins or jewellery at home. Its price fluctuates in line with the market price of gold, and each unit usually corresponds to one gram of gold.
Gold ETFs are appealing for the following reasons;
- They are supported by real gold, which is stored in vaults and is extremely pure (often 99.5% or more).
- bought and sold like shares; all you need is a trading account and a demat account.
- Unlike jewellery, you get exactly what you see, so there are no manufacturing fees or purity concerns.
- Like stocks, prices fluctuate continuously.
- Transparent and regulated; managed by mutual fund firms under SEBI’s supervision.
Read More: What is Gold ETF? Meaning & How to Invest Guide
Table of Differences between Sovereign Gold Bonds & Gold ETFs
Feature | Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) | Gold ETFs |
---|---|---|
About | SGBs are government-issued bonds that are linked to the price of gold, so you get the benefit of gold price movements without holding physical gold. | Gold ETFs are exchange-traded funds that aim to match the market price of gold and can be bought or sold just like shares. |
Backed by | They are backed by the Government of India and the prevailing market price of gold. | They are backed by physical gold of high purity, safely stored in secure vaults. |
Form | You receive a digital certificate; there’s no physical gold involved. | You hold them in your demat account in the form of ETF units. |
Minimum Investment | You can start with as little as 1 gram of gold. | You can start with 1 unit, which is usually equal to 1 gram of gold. |
Liquidity | You can sell them on the stock exchange, but trading volumes are often lower, so selling instantly at the best price might not always be possible. They work best if you hold till maturity. | You can buy or sell anytime during market hours, and liquidity is generally better than SGBs. |
Returns | Your returns come from any increase in the gold price, plus an extra 2.5% interest each year (which is taxable). | Your returns come purely from changes in the gold price; there’s no extra interest. |
Tax on Maturity | If you hold till maturity (8 years), any profit you make is completely tax-free. | There is no tax exemption at maturity; gains are taxed under capital gains rules. |
Interest | You earn 2.5% interest per year, paid every six months. This interest is taxable. | No interest is paid — your only gain is from the gold price. |
Best For | Great for long-term investors who can hold till maturity and enjoy tax-free gains plus interest along the way. | Ideal for those who want flexibility and the ability to enter or exit anytime without a long lock-in. |
Advantages of Investing in Sovereign Gold Bonds
Some of the advantages of investing in SBGs is given below:
- Gains on maturity that are tax-free – Any profit you make from the redemption of your SGBs is fully exempt from capital gains tax if you hold them until they mature, which is 8 years.
- Additional income each year – You receive 2.5% interest on your investment each year, which is paid every six months. In addition, the price of gold has increased.
- Do not be concerned about storage – Since your holdings are digitally stored and supported by the Indian government, there is no need for lockers or safes.
- High purity by default – You do not need to worry about verifying purity or quality because you are not holding actual gold.
- Government-backed – The Government of India guarantees the principal and interest payments, which makes them extremely safe.
Advantages of Investing in Gold ETFs
Advantages of investing in gold ETFs is given below:
- No problems with storage – You do not need to be concerned about home safety, insurance, or lockers. The investment account keeps your gold safe.
- High purity is assured – You know exactly what you’re getting because it’s typically 24 carat or 99.5% gold.
- Simple to buy and sell – You can enter or exit at any time during market hours because they are traded on the stock exchange just like shares.
- No manufacturing or waste fees – Unlike jewellery, you only pay for the actual value of the gold, not additional expenses.
- Transparent pricing – There are no unexpected costs because the price is determined in accordance with the gold market rate.
- Diversification – Gold helps balance your portfolio because it frequently moves differently from stocks and bonds.
Read Also: A Guide To Investing In Gold In India
Risks & Limitations of Sovereign Gold Bonds & Gold ETFs
GOLD ETFs
- Volatility of Gold Prices – Short-term fluctuations in gold prices can cause losses if you sell during a drop in prices.
- No Interest Income – Gold ETFs, in contrast to SGBs, do not pay interest; instead, your returns are centred on changes in the price of gold.
- Tax on Sale – There is no unique tax-free maturity benefit; gains are always taxed when sold.
- Changes in Liquidity – Extreme market conditions can increase bid-ask spreads, which could marginally lower your selling price, even though ETFs usually are liquid.
- Annual Costs – ETFs’ small annual expense ratio gradually reduces returns.
- No option for physical gold – Real gold cannot be delivered; it is only an investment in paper.
- Timing Trap in the Market – Some investors attempt to time their buys and sells because ETFs trade like shares, which, if done incorrectly, can reduce returns.
Sovereign Gold Bonds
- Dependency of Gold Prices – Even with the 2.5% annual interest, a decline in gold can lower your returns because SGB values fluctuate along with gold prices.
- Loss of Tax Benefit if Sold Early – If you sell before maturity, you lose the special tax-free benefit, and your gains will be subject to taxes.
- Low Liquidity in the Secondary Market – Finding buyers may not always be simple, and you might need to sell in the secondary market for less.
- High-Risk Secondary Market Buys – Although there isn’t an expense ratio, purchasing SGBs at a premium on the secondary market may result in overspending.
- No Delivery of Gold in Physical Form – Instead of actual gold, you get cash at maturity that is equal to the gold’s value.
- Extended Maturity Time – SGBs have an 8-year maturity, and the only ways to exit early are through an RBI buyback or an exchange sale after 5 years.
- Price Differences in Market Transactions – The RBI sets the issue price, but secondary market prices are subject to supply and demand in addition to the market value of gold.
Taxation – Sovereign Gold Bonds & Gold ETFs
Gold ETFs
The profit is considered short-term and subject to your standard income tax slab rate if you sell within a year.
Holding for more than a year is considered long-term and is subject to a flat 12.5% tax rate; indexation benefits are no longer available.
Gold ETFs are without interest; the only source of your return is changes in the price of gold.
SGBs, or Sovereign Gold Bonds
The main benefit is that any profit you make upon redemption is completely tax-free if you hold until maturity, that is, eight years.
Additionally, you receive 2.5% interest annually, which is paid every six months. However, this interest is subject to slab rate taxation as “Income from Other Sources.”
If you sell your SGB on the secondary market before it matures:
- Short-term gains are taxed at the slab rate if they are held for less than a year.
- Long-term gains are taxed at a rate of 12.5% (without indexation) after being held for more than 12 months.
Conclusion
SGBs are a great choice if you want to invest for a long time because they pay you interest regularly and tax-free gains when they mature. Gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are the best choice if you want to buy or sell at any time during market hours while enjoying flexibility. Which option is ideal for you will depend on your investment objectives. Either way, both are much better than leaving gold jewellery in a locker, since here, your gold is working for you.
S.NO. | Check Out These Interesting Posts You Might Enjoy! |
---|---|
1 | Mutual Fund vs ETF. Are They Same Or Different? |
2 | Best ETFs in India to Invest |
3 | ETF vs Stock – Which One is the Better Investment Option? |
4 | Gold ETF vs Gold Mutual Fund: Differences and Similarities |
5 | ETF vs Index Fund: Key Differences You Must Know |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the lock-in period for SGBs?
SGBs have an 8-year maturity, with an exit option from the 5th year onwards.
Can I trade SGBs before maturity?
Yes, they can be sold on stock exchanges, but liquidity may be low.
Do Gold ETFs give interest?
No, Gold ETFs only track gold prices and don’t pay any interest.
How much interest do SGBs offer?
SGBs offer 2.5% per annum on the initial investment, paid semi-annually.
Are SGB returns tax-free?
Yes, capital gains on SGBs at maturity are tax-free for individuals.